So, we’ve finally watched the most recent performance which LP did this spring, only just now. Still picking up our jaws from the floor, but already writing about it – this is where we’re at. Acting on the spur of the moment is usually risky, but not in this case, because LP’s acoustic performance of “When We’re High” for Sofar Sounds which she played several weeks ago was simply that good. The vocals, the interpretation, the precision, the elegance. A masterstroke.
Still frame from LP’s performance for Sofar Sounds in Los Angeles (2018)
The Sofar Sounds performance instantly reminded us of yet another rendition of “When We’re High” that left us speechless. Interestingly, that other one was so very different when it comes to the vibe. It was a backstage thing that took place during the Hangout Festival, and was meant to be just a simple, casual set up of only an interview with a couple of songs sung in between questions and stories. The thing is, there was nothing “just” about how LP sang “When We’re High” there. She just burned that little radio tent to the ground. But before we go into that, we need to take one step back.
The Lost On You album is many things, to us. It’s the music, obviously. But setting the music aside for a brief moment – this particular record, track after track after track, is like an emotional roadmap. Each song conjures up another story, another set of events or string of thought. No idea how that happened, it must have been some slow, imperceptible, gradual process. If we were to indicate the most intense areas on this peculiar map, the set would surely consist of “You Want It All,” “Suspicion,” “When We’re High” and “Muddy Waters.” It’s funny how even saying the titles of the songs activates myriads of memories and thrills. One of these memories is surely one warm April night in Paris, over a year ago, when LP played “When We’re High” for the very first time (as cliche as it is, most first times really have something forever bonding to them.) But we’re digressing, like two old ladies sitting next to the fireplace, going: “do you remember that blissful spring in Paris…?” Okay, hold on, taming these wandering minds of ours now. After all, we wanted to write about those two acoustic performances, right?
“When We’re High” has this fun, multi layered composition that gets brought to its fullest during live performances. We loved the way LP nailed describing this effect when asked by Bandsintown this February about her favorite song to perform:
“When We’re High” can be super fun to perform live, because I feel like people really move during it. I feel like it’s almost like a play where it has several different scenes and it’s super dramatic, but in a fun loving way.
So, two exquisite performances of “When We’re High.” The very first time LP played an acoustic version of the song, on May 20th of 2017, for Hangout Radio, and the very recent one, performed for Sofar Sounds in Los Angeles on April 18th, 2018, right smack in between her two Coachella weekends. The first one – sharp, intense, cutting to the bone; the latter – cool, calm and collected. Both being exactly like LP put it, like a theatre play, indeed. And although the performances seem miles away from one another, neither of them could be any better.
What we absolutely love about the Hangout Radio version is the fabulous rawness of the performance. To be honest, after the last two years, we still have trouble believing in the immensity of her singing talent. Whether it’s hearing her live, with our own ears, or watching the videos, we still can’t believe it (maybe we’re just fucking slow, who knows?). Especially in moments such as the Hangout performance, the very first “When We’re High” acoustic play, when LP had to take all the weight of this impressively difficult song (even from amongst LP’s ever-challenging work!) on herself. And she did, as always, with her unexpected vocals making everything disappear, together with all the minor arrangement hesitations that just have to be there during the first performance in a new set up. As raw edged as LP can make her voice sound, she didn’t seem to hold back on this effect, quite the opposite. As a result, the very last seconds of the song highlight even more of this impossible passage from her ice-cold soprano back to her ashen low timbre. Yes, even more. It even made an adult, responsible, serious person, being the host of the show, do very very weird things, like saying to his audience: “keep it tuned here, to Hangout Radio, ‘cause we will be having more artists, more performances, but probably not as… impressive as that was.” Well, that was probably quite right and we can’t blame him for not being able to resist.
Fast forward one year, to April 2018, and we’re looking at LP and the band seated in the most beautiful evening set-up, illuminated by blue fairy lights. And the spectacle that takes place right after you press play is nothing short of perfection. The song has visibly gone a long way over the past year and was served to the lucky Sofar audience as well-mastered as it gets – with LP gently, but decidedly, taking them through a story of love, love, and love, in all its different moments and shapes. We’re not sure how to go about describing it, but sometimes LP does something very unexpected to a song that already has some definite vibe kind of assigned, and manages to turn it all around. The regular “When We’re High” seems to have, more often than not, this strong, seductive, playful effect on the audience. But last April in LA, the equilibrium of the performance was shifted in favor of storytelling. We are tempted to call it The Bougainvillea Flowers Effect, if only it weren’t something that we made up just now, basing it on our impressions from the concert in Gardone Riviera. Maybe it’s the forthcoming Italian shows’ tension that’s got into our blood already, although it’s still one week away. It’s all about what we are left with when LP decides to downplay the performance and highlight the story. There is something… particular to how LP tells it, sings it there. And the instruments bring a spellbound background to it, sounding distinct and really beautiful. The soft beats of Eli’s cajon, the cool bass line, the delicate ukulele, and this little something of the gypsy romanticism to the guitar line and LP’s swirling vocals. So fine.
Interestingly, even when LP talks about “When We’re High,” she usually mentions this duality that likely makes it such an excellent song. First, the duality of how she sees the song herself:
It’s probably not my deepest song… but it is, in a way. It’s about staying high on the good stuff in life and forgetting the bad stuff for a minute. (Music-news .com, November 2017)
Then, the duality of the love story behind it and how different it can be:
It’s wanting to access that place in your relationship where you are at your best with your lover. And then sometimes the downfall of it being – do we only get here when we are actually high? (Schon Magazine, December, 2017)
And finally, the duality of the original inspiration while writing the song:
That’s just me trying to get back to that, that love spot, you know? I’m kind of fascinated by the point of impact, when you’re suddenly, ‘Oh, shit, I’m in love with this person!’ And then I’m morosely fascinated with when it ends. That moment that the molecule… [mimes breaking apart with her hands] detaches from the other molecule and you’re like ‘Oh… It’s going…’ It like, it breaks my heart to even think about. It breaks my heart when – I don’t know if you yourself have been in this experience – but [I’ve] now been on both sides of the coin, the one where it sucks falling out of love with someone and telling them that and dealing with it, and [the one where] it sucks when you see it happening. It’s the worst. (Spindle Magazine, December, 2017)
Here they are for you, two masterpieces, each of another breed, each bringing a brilliant new element to what’s already out there.
✶ LP sings “When We’re High” (acoustic) for Hangout Radio (2017) (the song starts at 1:15)